Case Strength Builder
Hosted static delivery (WP-CS-004). Read-only operator surface; passage selection is client-side and non-destructive.
Imported source
Mill's On Liberty · 189 characters · 2 passages selected
Readable selected passages
passage-one
The worth of a state, in the long run, is the worth of the individuals composing it.
passage-two
A state which dwarfs its people will find that with small men no great thing can really be accomplished.
Import state (read-only)
{
"attribution": "Mill's On Liberty",
"author": "John Stuart Mill",
"fixture": "On Liberty",
"passage_count": 2,
"source_length": 189,
"source_registered": true,
"title": "On Liberty"
}Public criticism cases
Anonymous cases are retrievable immediately with an initial review pending label; no account or contact is required.
{
"account_required": false,
"cases": [
{
"case": {
"admissibility_state": "admissible",
"artifact": "The same wording recurs later in the edition.",
"case_id": "public-addition",
"final_disposition_id": "public-parent-disposition",
"final_response_id": "public-parent-response",
"justification": "The second passage shows the same issue.",
"kind": "addition",
"parent_case_id": "public-parent",
"provenance": "anonymous public addition",
"public_status": "closed",
"received_at": "2026-09-11T21:47:03.104397+00:00",
"submission_batch_id": null,
"target": {
"edition_id": "release-2c19b326b814c945",
"element_id": null,
"span": null
},
"workflow_state": "responded"
},
"disposition": {
"case_id": "public-parent",
"decided_at": "2026-09-11T21:47:03.104402+00:00",
"decided_by": "editor-1",
"disposition_id": "public-parent-disposition",
"effect": "An editorial qualification is recorded.",
"evidence_id": "public-parent-decision",
"kind": "merits",
"rationale": "The concern is substantiated against the current edition."
},
"parent_case": {
"admissibility_state": "admissible",
"artifact": "The first passage needs a qualification.",
"case_id": "public-parent",
"final_disposition_id": "public-parent-disposition",
"final_response_id": "public-parent-response",
"justification": null,
"kind": "standalone",
"parent_case_id": null,
"provenance": "anonymous public submission",
"public_status": "closed",
"received_at": "2026-09-11T21:47:03.104383+00:00",
"submission_batch_id": null,
"target": {
"edition_id": "release-2c19b326b814c945",
"element_id": null,
"span": null
},
"workflow_state": "responded"
},
"response": {
"case_id": "public-parent",
"content": "We accept the concern and have recorded a qualification.",
"disposition_id": "public-parent-disposition",
"published_at": "2026-09-11T21:47:03.104404+00:00",
"published_by": "editor-1",
"response_id": "public-parent-response"
}
},
{
"case": {
"admissibility_state": "inadmissible",
"artifact": "DISCOUNT WATCHES CLICK HERE",
"case_id": "public-junk",
"final_disposition_id": "public-junk-disposition",
"final_response_id": "public-junk-response",
"justification": null,
"kind": "standalone",
"parent_case_id": null,
"provenance": "anonymous public submission",
"public_status": "closed",
"received_at": "2026-09-11T21:47:03.104348+00:00",
"submission_batch_id": null,
"target": {
"edition_id": "release-2c19b326b814c945",
"element_id": null,
"span": null
},
"workflow_state": "responded"
},
"disposition": {
"case_id": "public-junk",
"decided_at": "2026-09-11T21:47:03.104367+00:00",
"decided_by": "intake-1",
"disposition_id": "public-junk-disposition",
"effect": "No edition change follows from this non-merits rejection.",
"evidence_id": "public-junk-decision",
"kind": "non_merits",
"rationale": "Rejected as spam during admissibility review."
},
"parent_case": null,
"response": {
"case_id": "public-junk",
"content": "This submission was removed as spam; it was not judged on merit.",
"disposition_id": "public-junk-disposition",
"published_at": "2026-09-11T21:47:03.104371+00:00",
"published_by": "intake-1",
"response_id": "public-junk-response"
}
},
{
"case": {
"admissibility_state": "admissible",
"artifact": "The first passage needs a qualification.",
"case_id": "public-parent",
"final_disposition_id": "public-parent-disposition",
"final_response_id": "public-parent-response",
"justification": null,
"kind": "standalone",
"parent_case_id": null,
"provenance": "anonymous public submission",
"public_status": "closed",
"received_at": "2026-09-11T21:47:03.104383+00:00",
"submission_batch_id": null,
"target": {
"edition_id": "release-2c19b326b814c945",
"element_id": null,
"span": null
},
"workflow_state": "responded"
},
"disposition": {
"case_id": "public-parent",
"decided_at": "2026-09-11T21:47:03.104402+00:00",
"decided_by": "editor-1",
"disposition_id": "public-parent-disposition",
"effect": "An editorial qualification is recorded.",
"evidence_id": "public-parent-decision",
"kind": "merits",
"rationale": "The concern is substantiated against the current edition."
},
"parent_case": null,
"response": {
"case_id": "public-parent",
"content": "We accept the concern and have recorded a qualification.",
"disposition_id": "public-parent-disposition",
"published_at": "2026-09-11T21:47:03.104404+00:00",
"published_by": "editor-1",
"response_id": "public-parent-response"
}
},
{
"case": {
"admissibility_state": "pending",
"artifact": "The second passage appears to overstate its conclusion.",
"case_id": "public-pending",
"final_disposition_id": null,
"final_response_id": null,
"justification": null,
"kind": "standalone",
"parent_case_id": null,
"provenance": "anonymous public submission",
"public_status": "initial review pending",
"received_at": "2026-09-11T21:47:03.104336+00:00",
"submission_batch_id": null,
"target": {
"edition_id": "release-2c19b326b814c945",
"element_id": null,
"span": null
},
"workflow_state": "admissibility_review"
},
"disposition": null,
"parent_case": null,
"response": null
}
],
"edition_id": "release-49860f4589b97208"
}